Supratik wrote: ↑Tue Feb 06, 2018 1:14 pm
Pure garbage. He doesn't know how Modi functions. Modi is not Khilji that he will execute all those who worked for the previous regime. Except the recalcitrant he will make them work for him. Home ministry has worked the best in near memory. Naxalite violence is down and Islamist violence outside Kashmir is near zero. And after all these things like demo and GST he rants about no reforms. Nalapat is a reasonable guy. Expected better.
Precisely.
Frankly, it is very easy to demolish the argument that "Modi rode to power on a wave of Hindutva/Ram Mandir/Hindu Causes/Ending All Minority Appeasement in 2014, but has since betrayed/abandoned them."
Let's assume for one minute that it is true: Modi is simply a conniving and conscience-less individual who promised Hindus that he would turn this country into Hindu Rashtra (I don't remember anything like that, but anyway, let's say my memory is bad). Let us assume this was a singular or major factor that made overwhelming numbers of people vote for him and got him 282 seats in LS 2014 elections.
But for Modi to betray these very causes (that allegedly won him the last election) it isn't sufficient that he is merely conniving and conscience-less. He also has to be stupid. No? I mean, how can any intelligent person abandon the very cause that brought him the Gaddi, if he aims to do it again? For this to be true, has to be so weak-minded and gullible that 5 years in Lutyens Delhi have magically sapped his political instincts and replaced them with Nehruvian secularism.
This is a guy who has never lost an election. He has been Gujarat CM 3 times, undefeated, and then PM of India. So even if he doesn't really care about Hindus, what about the argument that he is also stupid/gullible/easily influenced to the point of totally losing his political instincts? I will leave it to forum members to decide how realistic or preposterous that argument is.
The far simpler and more obvious explanation is that the "wave of Hindutva" that swept Modi to power existed only in the minds of those who perpetually complain about Modi not acting on it. I certainly did not vote for Modi while labouring under any such delusion. I would really love to see evidence, hard data, that in any way indicates that such a "wave of Hindutva" was singularly or even majorly responsible for his 2014 victory.